A big white blob is sitting on my counter

A big white blob is sitting on my counter

Can you guess what this is?

I’ll give you a hint: It’s all wrapped up (with holes cut into the top) so that my cats won’t get to it. Stumped? Ok, here’s another hint: They really, really want to eat it, which I think is gross.
Still confused? Ok, here’s a picture of what’s inside:

It’s Amish Friendship [...]